How might the decision to make ethical veganism a philosophical belief affect employers?

Jordi Casamitjana was dismissed in 2018 by The League Against Cruel sports for gross misconduct. Mr Casamitjana, an ethical vegan, claims that his dismissal came after telling colleagues that their employer’s pension fund was being invested in companies involved in animal testing. His solicitors claimed that the decision to dismiss was made because of his beliefs around ethical veganism.

At an Employment Tribunal hearing in Norwich last week, a judge needed to decide if ethical veganism was a philosophical or religious belief, and therefore protected under the Equalities Act 2010. Ethical vegans eat a plant-based diet, avoid wearing clothes made of leather or wool and products that are tested on animals.

Mr Casamitiana’s lawyers claim that if the case was successful, it would establish that the belief entitles ethical vegans to protection from discrimination in the workplace.

The Judge’s decision, made on 3 January, was that ethical veganism is indeed a philosophical belief and should receive similar protection to religion in the workplace.

It is worth bearing in mind that this hearing was primarily about ethical veganism as a philosophical belief, and that a second hearing, will be about the specifics regarding Mr Casamitjana’s dismissal.

What this decision means for employers?

The Judge’s decision does not change any laws per se. However, it does ‘shine a light’ regarding the future treatment of ethical vegans in the workplace and the steps that employers might want to consider. These may include:

  • Updating policies to reflect ethical veganism as a philosophical belief.
  • Ensure that ethical vegans are given the same protections as other employees with religious or philosophical beliefs.
  • At a practical level, to review the choice of food available in workplace eateries, choice of materials for staff uniforms, any leather or wool used in office furniture, toiletries and cleaning products and of course pension fund investments.

It does seem that Friday’s ruling is a significant one for employers of working people in the UK who have specifically chosen an ethical vegan lifestyle.

If you are an employer and need any advice on this subject, contact the Employment Team at Downs Solicitors for more information.

More blog posts from this author

With the latest Government advice - Do I still need work from home?

The Government’s roadmap identified that until England reached Step 4 of the Roadmap, employees should work from home where they can. As we are aware Step 4 has been delayed from 21st June to 19th July 2021 and therefore, employers should continue with home working wherever possible until the 19th July.  

Changing an employee’s terms and conditions is challenging both from a legal and trust perspective.

British Gas has been in the media over recent weeks due to the “fire and rehire” approach with their employees.

Do you need to offer enhanced shared parental leave pay?

When shared parental leave was introduced in 2015, one of the concerns was whether an employer would need to offer enhanced shared parental leave pay if the employer provided enhanced adoption and/or maternity leave pay.

More blog posts from this sector

With the latest Government advice - Do I still need work from home?

The Government’s roadmap identified that until England reached Step 4 of the Roadmap, employees should work from home where they can. As we are aware Step 4 has been delayed from 21st June to 19th July 2021 and therefore, employers should continue with home working wherever possible until the 19th July.  

Changing an employee’s terms and conditions is challenging both from a legal and trust perspective.

British Gas has been in the media over recent weeks due to the “fire and rehire” approach with their employees.

What are restrictive covenants and why do I need them?

I own a start-up which grew very quickly and a few years ago I hired in a couple of senior personnel to help run the business. After 5 years, one of these senior hires is now leaving the business and going to a company which isn’t a direct competitor but operates in a very similar field.

Our Team

Meet all of the team at Downslaw


Cobham

15A High Street
Cobham
Surrey
KT11 3DH

T: 01932 589599
F: 01932 505087

DX: 46102 COBHAM

Dorking

156 High Street
Dorking
Surrey
RH4 1BQ

T: 01306 880110
F: 01306 471230

DX: 57300 DORKING

Godalming

The Tanners
75 Meadrow
Godalming
Surrey
GU7 3HS

T: 01483 861848
F: 01483 431965

DX: 58308 GODALMING 1